top of page
Writer's pictureE. G. Runyan

Catholicism VS Protestantism: A Blog Series




Today I finished watching this invigorating debate between British Catholic George Farmer and Protestant Allie Beth Stuckey. And wow, what a debate! I always love a good discussion and this by far was the best I’ve ever seen. Every minute was worth it. I walked away with a clearer understanding of Catholicism and a stronger faith in Protestantism. Just as importantly, I walked away with more confidence in how to address Catholicism in my own life.


I’m surrounded by wonderful, kind, loving Catholics here in Kansas who I love, respect, and believe have a saving faith and love for Christ. But that doesn’t mean that I don’t hold deep issues with the Roman Catholic church. And those are issues I feel called to address, because as I Christian I am called to be able to articulate what I believe about Christ’s Sacrifice for me, and why I believe it. Last summer I debated three Catholic teens on an online forum, specifically on issues like praying to the saints, the immaculate heart of Mary, and the rosary/the sacraments. We didn’t get anywhere, and I, quite frankly, was dissatisfied with my side of the argument. It wasn’t that I don’t firmly stand beside what I said then. I do. It’s that I’m not pleased with how I presented it. 


I wasn’t rude, and I didn’t disrespect them or their beliefs, but I came to the table with a very basic understanding of the Roman Catholic Church and a handful of misconceptions besides. I wish I had been more equipped and I wish I had been able to offer them more to think about and consider. 


I’ve long struggled with the issues I see in Catholicism, but I didn’t understand all of the nuances of the Roman Catholic Church. So, I naturally started to research.  I read a long email discussion between two friends, one of which was and is a Protestant, the other a former Protestant who converted to Catholicism. I read debates, I watched debates, I read Catholic articles and I read Protestant articles. 

In scouring the internet I came across a lot of arrogance and misconceptions on both sides, but all together, I’m pleased to say that I now have what I think is a fair understanding of Catholicism and its teachings. I don’t pretend to know or understand all of their Traditions, feasts, and practices, but I do think I have a good grasp on the main components of the Catholic faith. 


Overall, I’ve found this whole deep dive fascinating. There’s a lot about Catholicism I didn’t previously know, and a lot of the Protestants in my life don’t know about it either. I think that if we all, Catholics and Protestants, spent some time really digging into what the other party believes, we’d come to a new understanding.


But I don’t think we’d necessarily come to an agreement.


I think the Roman Catholic Church has a twisted view of salvation; one that invokes fear, confusion, inconsistencies, and unrepented sin. Infant baptism, the process of losing your faith through “mortal” sin, and the practice of confession, I believe undermine and disrespect the beauty of Christ’s sacrifice and love for us.


But there’s a lot more to it than that, and that’s why I’m starting this blog series discussing Catholicism and Protestantism.


I think this is worth a good discussion.


Watch the first part of the Farmer-Stuckey debate here.

159 views20 comments

Related Posts

See All

20 Comments


Jack Cuison
Jack Cuison
May 14

yesss i love candace owens and allie beth stuckey!! great post

Like
E. G. Runyan
E. G. Runyan
May 14
Replying to

They're both really talented women! Thanks for reading!

Like

Guest
May 03

That video was good! Thanks for sharing it, Emma!!

Like
E. G. Runyan
E. G. Runyan
May 03
Replying to

Glad you enjoyed it! Of course!

Like

Guest
May 01

okay, so as a Catholic, I am very interested in this blog series. A lot of the time I, as a Catholic, get a very Catholic view point of Catholicism vs. Protestantism debates, so I'm very interested in seeing it from a different view point!!!

Like
E. G. Runyan
E. G. Runyan
May 01
Replying to

That's awesome!!! And I can't wait to hear all of your thoughts. I think this is going to be fun. It's definitely worth the discussion.

Like

Guest
May 01

I watched the video! It was so interesting! Can't wait for the next post!

Like
E. G. Runyan
E. G. Runyan
May 01
Replying to

Thank you! I'm glad you found it interesting!

Like

N P
N P
May 01

This sounds so interesting! Can't wait!

Like
E. G. Runyan
E. G. Runyan
May 01
Replying to

Thanks NP!

Like
bottom of page